Movement 02 of 08

Latin America & Caribbean

Mexico, Central America, South America and the Caribbean

Mexico is part of this movement, not North America. The Caribbean is integral to the region, not an appendix to Latin America.

Broad window
Thu 20 May, about 1:00 PM to 4:00 PM Toronto timeIn São Paulo: Thu 20 May, about 2:00 PM to 5:00 PM. The hours belong to the conversation, not to one region: contributors from anywhere take part wherever the question needs them.
Taking part
Contributor expressions of interest are not open.

The question in play

How must leadership change when the systems people depend on are changing faster than institutions can adapt?

The relay's opening question, carried from Toronto. North America transforms it live, and this movement receives that version when its own begins.

Regional reality

Regional Reality

Latin America and the Caribbean is a region of extraordinary adaptive capacity operating through economic, institutional and territorial systems that too often make adaptation necessary. People, firms and communities continually find ways to work, trade, migrate, care, innovate and recover amid informality, inequality, insecurity, climate exposure and uneven institutional capacity. The leadership challenge is therefore not simply to make the region more adaptable. It is to convert the adaptive capacity already present in society into productive, trusted and resilient systems that reduce the need for people to succeed around institutions rather than through them.

Adaptation → Fragmentation → Transformation

What these three words mean here
Adaptation
People, firms and communities find ways to work, trade, migrate, care, innovate and recover within incomplete systems.
Fragmentation
That adaptive capability operates across uneven productive, institutional, territorial and social systems which do not consistently convert capability into secure, scalable opportunity. It is not shorthand for government failure.
Transformation
Redesigning systems so adaptive capability becomes productivity, opportunity, security, legitimacy and resilience rather than a permanent workaround.

Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

The region's inquiry is organised around:

  • Adaptive capacity and how systems channel it
  • Informality as livelihood and as symptom
  • Institutional performance as the basis of legitimacy
  • Technology diffusion across uneven productive systems
  • Resilience as a present-day portfolio decision

This is what LEAD48's research sees in Latin America & Caribbean: the tensions, the evidence and the questions it raises. It is where the inquiry starts, not a boundary around it. The conversation needs people who can strengthen it, challenge it, complicate it or take it somewhere it has not gone, and a well-evidenced challenge to this reading is as strong a contribution as support for it.

Prevailing conditions Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What is changing here?

Each condition is backed by the sources listed with it. Open a source to see what it says and where it stops.

Adaptive capacity exceeds the capacity of many systems to channel it productively

People, firms and communities across the region are persistently inventive, but productive systems convert that inventiveness into secure, scalable opportunity unevenly.

Detail and scope

The pattern shows up in productivity levels, in the gap between small firms and large ones, in the scale of informal work, in wide territorial variation within single countries, and in how rarely productive transformation reaches the places that most need it.

Scope: A regional pattern, not a uniform one: it holds differently in Mexico, in the Andean economies, in Brazil, in the Southern Cone and across the Caribbean.

View the other 4 conditions

Informality is both a livelihood adaptation and a symptom of fragmented pathways into productive participation

Informal work is how millions of people participate in the economy. It is also evidence that formal pathways are missing, unreachable or not worth their cost.

Detail and scope

Treating informality only as non-compliance misreads it. It is a rational adaptation to systems that do not offer a viable route in, and any transformation that ignores the livelihood it provides removes the adaptation before the alternative exists.

Scope: Its shape differs by country, sector and territory, and between urban and rural economies.

Institutional legitimacy increasingly depends on whether institutions convert authority into experienced results

Legitimacy is being earned or lost in delivery: what people experience from institutions, not what institutions are entitled to do.

Detail and scope

This is a question about performance and delivery rather than about any party or government. Where authority does not become a result people can feel, trust follows the experience, not the mandate.

Scope: Framed as institutional performance, deliberately not as partisan politics.

Technology can widen rather than automatically close productive gaps

Where diffusion, talent and institutional capacity are uneven, frontier technology tends to reach the firms and places already best able to use it.

Detail and scope

The question is not adoption but diffusion: who gets access, who has the skills and complementary investment to use it, and which institutions can absorb it. Adoption alone is not transformation.

Scope: No claim is made here about the size of technology's effect on regional productivity.

Repeated shocks turn resilience into a present-day portfolio problem

Hurricanes, floods, droughts, price shocks and fiscal stress recur faster than fiscal capacity replenishes, so resilience is a question of what to fund now.

Detail and scope

For small states in particular, each shock consumes the fiscal space that the next one will require. That makes resilience a live allocation decision, not a future environmental concern.

Scope: Sharpest in the Caribbean and in exposed territories across the mainland.

  • Source World Bank (2024)

    World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

    Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

    Published
    2024-11-12
    Evidence period
    Announced at COP29, November 2024
    Geography
    Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
    Limitations
    An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.

Inside the region Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

One region, several realities

None of these stands for the others.

  • Mexico

    Productive integration and manufacturing depth alongside informality, sharp territorial inequality, migration through and from the country, and an open question about industrial upgrading. Part of Latin America & Caribbean, and not representative of it.

View the other 5
  • Central America

    Migration as a structural feature, extensive informality, productive structures concentrated in a few value chains, high climate exposure and territorial vulnerability, and the question of where opportunity is actually created.

  • Andean and northern South America

    Productive transformation attempted alongside informality and inequality, large migration movements, resource economies, contested territorial governance, and Indigenous and Afro-descendant realities that are central rather than peripheral.

  • Brazil

    Continental scale: Amazonia, digital public infrastructure, active industrial policy, deep inequality, Indigenous governance, an unusual energy position and a live productive-transformation debate. Brazil is not a proxy for South America.

  • Southern Cone

    Wide institutional variation, productivity and technology questions, ageing in some contexts, macroeconomic volatility, productive clusters and advanced digital government in places.

    • Source AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay (2024)

      Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

      Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally in the United Nations E-Government Development Index between 2022 and 2024, with a score of 0.9006. It remains first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas after the United States (0.9194). The work is led by AGESIC under the Agenda Uruguay Digital 2025.

      Published
      2024
      Evidence period
      UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022
      Geography
      Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean
      Limitations
      A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.
  • Caribbean

    Small-state economics: debt and fiscal space, disaster exposure, food and energy import dependence, tourism concentration, regional integration and implementation capacity, and resilience financing. The question it puts to the world is what the Caribbean knows about leadership under constraint that larger economies may not.

    What does the Caribbean know about leadership under constraint that larger economies may not?

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
    • Source Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (2025)

      Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

      The "25 by 2025 Initiative", which set out to cut the region's food import bill of "more than $6B" by 25 percent by the end of 2025, has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5. CARICOM cites "uncertainties in the global trade arena", Hurricane Beryl's effect on agriculture and supply-chain disruption. It reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund.

      Published
      2025-02-21
      Evidence period
      2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030
      Geography
      CARICOM member states
      Limitations
      A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.

Who experiences the region differently Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

Who experiences this differently?

No region is a single story. These groups are named from the evidence, not as a complete list.

  • Indigenous peoples as governors, owners and producers

    Indigenous communities in the region hold governance systems, territorial stewardship, productive knowledge, enterprise and institutional design of their own. Representing them only through vulnerability or exclusion misses what already works. The question is what leadership knowledge exists in communities that conventional institutions have failed to recognise or scale.

View the other 4 groups
  • Afro-descendant communities as economic and territorial actors

    Afro-descendant communities across the region carry productive traditions, territorial claims, enterprise and community institutions. They appear here as economic and territorial actors, not as a disadvantage statistic.

  • People who move, and the systems that move with them

    Migration in this region is a system, not a crisis frame: it connects labour markets, skills, demographics, remittances, entrepreneurship, families, care and regional integration, and it shapes productive structures at both ends of the journey.

  • Communities living with insecurity

    Insecurity is a real regional condition and is treated here through its effect on institutional capacity, investment, opportunity, productive participation, trust and daily life, without sensationalism and without political claims the evidence does not support.

  • Micro, small and medium enterprises

    Most employment in the region sits in firms that are small, often informal, and rarely connected to the productive systems that would let them grow. They are where adaptive capacity is most visible and least converted.

What the evidence complicates Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What might we be getting wrong?

  • Common assumption

    Informality is simply a problem to eliminate.

    What the evidence shows

    It is also how millions of people work, trade and care. Removing it without building a viable pathway into productive participation removes the livelihood before the alternative exists. The leadership question is conversion, not elimination.

View the other 4 assumptions
  • Common assumption

    Growth will eventually solve inequality.

    What the evidence shows

    The region's own record shows growth arriving without the distribution or the productive participation that would convert it into opportunity. Who takes part in growth is a design question, not a by-product of it.

  • Common assumption

    Technology adoption equals transformation.

    What the evidence shows

    Where diffusion, talent and institutional capacity are uneven, adoption concentrates gains among those already able to use it. Transformation depends on who gets access, who can absorb it, and whether institutions can carry it.

  • Common assumption

    The Caribbean is a smaller version of Latin America.

    What the evidence shows

    Small-state economics is a different problem: debt and fiscal space, import dependence for food and energy, disaster exposure, tourism concentration, and implementation capacity measured in individual people rather than departments. The Caribbean is integral to the region and distinct within it.

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
    • Source Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (2025)

      Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

      The "25 by 2025 Initiative", which set out to cut the region's food import bill of "more than $6B" by 25 percent by the end of 2025, has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5. CARICOM cites "uncertainties in the global trade arena", Hurricane Beryl's effect on agriculture and supply-chain disruption. It reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund.

      Published
      2025-02-21
      Evidence period
      2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030
      Geography
      CARICOM member states
      Limitations
      A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.
  • Common assumption

    Resilience means bouncing back.

    What the evidence shows

    Where shocks recur faster than fiscal capacity replenishes, returning to the previous state guarantees the next loss. Resilience here is a present-day allocation decision about what to protect, fund, scale and stop.

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.

Leadership challenges Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What must leaders do?

The conversations this region will prioritise. Not a ranking of the region's biggest problems.

  1. Productive Transformation

    How do leaders convert adaptive capacity into productive participation rather than permanent workarounds?

    The region's inventiveness is not in doubt. What is in doubt is whether the systems around it turn that inventiveness into secure, scalable work.

    4P: People, Process, PortfolioSDGs: 8, 9, 10

    Rests on: Adaptive capacity exceeds the capacity of many systems to channel it productively; Informality is both a livelihood adaptation and a symptom of fragmented pathways into productive participation

View the other 4 priorities
  1. Institutional Performance

    What must institutions deliver before people experience them as worth trusting?

    Trust is treated here as an outcome of delivery, not as a campaign. The question is what has to be converted from authority into result.

    4P: Process, PeopleSDGs: 16, 9

    Rests on: Institutional legitimacy increasingly depends on whether institutions convert authority into experienced results

    • Source AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay (2024)

      Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

      Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally in the United Nations E-Government Development Index between 2022 and 2024, with a score of 0.9006. It remains first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas after the United States (0.9194). The work is led by AGESIC under the Agenda Uruguay Digital 2025.

      Published
      2024
      Evidence period
      UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022
      Geography
      Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean
      Limitations
      A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.
  2. Technology Diffusion

    Who captures value when frontier technologies enter fragmented productive systems?

    Diffusion, not adoption, is the leadership variable: who gets access, who can absorb it, and which institutions can carry it.

    4P: People, Process, PortfolioSDGs: 8, 9, 10

    Rests on: Technology can widen rather than automatically close productive gaps; Adaptive capacity exceeds the capacity of many systems to channel it productively

  3. Resilience Under Constraint

    What must leaders protect, fund and stop when shocks recur faster than fiscal capacity replenishes?

    Where each shock consumes the fiscal space the next one needs, resilience becomes an allocation decision taken now.

    4P: Planet, Portfolio, ProcessSDGs: 13, 9, 1

    Rests on: Repeated shocks turn resilience into a present-day portfolio problem

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
  4. Leadership From Lived Systems

    What changes when communities are treated as designers, owners and knowledge holders rather than recipients?

    The region already contains governance, stewardship and productive knowledge that institutions have not recognised or scaled.

    4P: People, Planet, ProcessSDGs: 10, 16, 17

    Rests on: Adaptive capacity exceeds the capacity of many systems to channel it productively; Institutional legitimacy increasingly depends on whether institutions convert authority into experienced results

Tensions Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What trade-offs must they navigate?

These are to investigate, not to resolve on a slide. Each side of a tension is a legitimate demand.

  • Adaptation and transformation

    Adaptive capacity keeps people afloat today; transformation asks them to give up the workaround before the replacement is proven.

    Protecting what works now is legitimate. So is refusing to make the workaround permanent.

View the other 4 tensions
  • Formality and viability

    Formalisation promises protection and access; it can also price out the livelihood it was meant to secure.

    Formal systems create rights and scale. Viability is what keeps a family fed this month.

  • Speed and institutional legitimacy

    Delivery pressure rewards moving quickly; legitimacy is built through processes that take time.

    People are waiting now. Consent is what makes a decision hold.

  • Growth and distribution

    Growth expands what there is to share; distribution decides whether participation widens with it.

    Without growth there is less to allocate. Without distribution, growth changes little for most people.

  • Immediate survival and long-term resilience

    Fiscal space spent on recovery is not available for the protection that would reduce the next loss.

    Recovering now is unavoidable. Protecting later is what stops the cycle.

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.

Regional responses and experiments

What is being tried

Every response is classified as established, promising, early, contested, failed, and documented with the Response Case Protocol: Attempt → Conditions → Mechanism → Evidence → Outcome → For whom → Cost / trade-off → Unintended effects → Transferability.

Caribbean crisis financing and climate-resilient debt clauses Established / emerging
Attempt
Caribbean small states adopted debt instruments that pause repayments when a disaster hits, alongside wider crisis-financing arrangements.
Conditions
Small states carrying high debt, high disaster exposure and thin fiscal buffers, borrowing from multilateral lenders.
Mechanism
A clause written into loan agreements that defers principal and interest for a defined period once a qualifying event occurs, keeping cash in the country when recovery costs peak.
Evidence
The World Bank's November 2024 expansion of Climate Resilient Debt Clauses.
Outcome
The clause allows deferral of principal and interest "for up to two years", was expanded to cover all natural disasters and to 45 eligible small states, of which 14 had written it into loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.
For whom
Governments and populations of participating small states.
Cost / trade-off
Deferral is not forgiveness: the obligation returns, and eligibility is not adoption.
Unintended effects
Not established from this source.
Transferability
The instrument travels wherever a lender will write the clause. What does not travel automatically is the negotiating capacity to secure it, or the fiscal position that makes deferral useful rather than merely delaying.
  • Source World Bank (2024)

    World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

    Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

    Published
    2024-11-12
    Evidence period
    Announced at COP29, November 2024
    Geography
    Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
    Limitations
    An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
CARICOM 25 by 2025, extended to 25 by 2025+5 Mixed / continuing
Attempt
CARICOM set out to cut the region's food import bill by 25 percent by the end of 2025, then extended the target to 2030.
Conditions
A group of small states importing most of their food, exposed to hurricanes and to global supply-chain shocks.
Mechanism
Coordinated regional production targets, investment in cold storage, farm-to-market roads and processing, and a regional agricultural loan fund.
Evidence
CARICOM's February 2025 Heads of Government communiqué.
Outcome
The initiative has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5, citing trade uncertainty, Hurricane Beryl and supply-chain disruption. CARICOM reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund. Whether the import bill itself fell by the target share is not established here.
For whom
CARICOM member states and their food producers.
Cost / trade-off
An extended timeline is a real cost: the original target date passed without the stated reduction being demonstrated.
Unintended effects
A production increase reported at regional level can coexist with an unchanged import bill, which is why the two must not be read as the same result.
Transferability
The coordination mechanism is transferable between small-state groupings. The specific target is not: it depends on what a region can actually grow.
  • Source Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (2025)

    Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

    The "25 by 2025 Initiative", which set out to cut the region's food import bill of "more than $6B" by 25 percent by the end of 2025, has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5. CARICOM cites "uncertainties in the global trade arena", Hurricane Beryl's effect on agriculture and supply-chain disruption. It reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund.

    Published
    2025-02-21
    Evidence period
    2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030
    Geography
    CARICOM member states
    Limitations
    A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.
Explore all cases (7 more)
Costa Rica's medical-device value chain Established, with continuing bottlenecks
Attempt
Costa Rica built a medical-device manufacturing and export cluster over successive decades of investment promotion and skills policy.
Conditions
A small economy with political stability, an educated workforce and sustained institutional attention to investment attraction.
Mechanism
Investment promotion, free-zone arrangements, technical education aligned to the sector, and supplier development to move local firms into the chain.
Outcome
Documented as an established cluster. The specific figures, and the extent to which domestic suppliers have moved up the value chain, remain to be verified.
For whom
Workers and firms inside the cluster; the distribution beyond it is not established.
Cost / trade-off
Continuing bottlenecks in supplier upgrading and in spreading the gains beyond the cluster's own territory.
Unintended effects
Not established from the material reviewed.
Transferability
The sequencing is widely cited as transferable. What is context-dependent is the decades of institutional continuity behind it.
Uruguay's digital-state transformation Established trajectory / continuing
Attempt
Uruguay pursued a sustained national digital-government programme, led by a dedicated agency under a national digital agenda.
Conditions
A small, institutionally stable country with a single national agency carrying the mandate across administrations.
Mechanism
Shared digital infrastructure, interoperability and service redesign under AGESIC and the Agenda Uruguay Digital.
Evidence
AGESIC's report of Uruguay's position in the United Nations E-Government Development Index, 2024.
Outcome
Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally between 2022 and 2024, scoring 0.9006, first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas.
For whom
Users of national digital services. The index measures provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services reach the people furthest from them.
Cost / trade-off
Not published in the material reviewed.
Unintended effects
An index position can rise while access remains uneven, which is why this is a trajectory rather than a completed outcome.
Transferability
Institutional continuity across administrations is the transferable ingredient, and the hardest to copy.
  • Source AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay (2024)

    Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

    Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally in the United Nations E-Government Development Index between 2022 and 2024, with a score of 0.9006. It remains first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas after the United States (0.9194). The work is led by AGESIC under the Agenda Uruguay Digital 2025.

    Published
    2024
    Evidence period
    UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022
    Geography
    Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean
    Limitations
    A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.
Costa Rica: Indigenous forest leadership Promising / in implementation
Attempt
Indigenous territories in Costa Rica exercise forest governance and stewardship within national conservation and payment arrangements.
Conditions
Recognised territorial rights, an established national conservation framework, and community institutions able to hold the responsibility.
Mechanism
Community governance of forest territory, linked to national schemes that pay for environmental services.
Outcome
Documented as in implementation. Measured stewardship outcomes attributable to the arrangement are not established here.
For whom
The Indigenous communities holding the territory.
Cost / trade-off
Not established.
Unintended effects
Not established.
Transferability
The design principle, that communities govern what they hold, is transferable. The legal recognition it depends on is not automatic elsewhere.
Indigenous Economy Programme, AIDESEP, Peruvian Amazon In implementation / promising
Attempt
An Indigenous federation in the Peruvian Amazon developed an economic programme run by and for its member communities.
Conditions
Organised Indigenous representation with its own governance, operating in territories where state productive systems reach weakly.
Mechanism
Community-owned enterprise and value chains designed around territorial knowledge rather than external project design.
Outcome
Documented as in implementation. Scale and measured economic outcomes are not established here.
For whom
Member communities of the federation.
Cost / trade-off
Not established.
Unintended effects
Not established.
Transferability
The ownership model is the transferable element: the programme belongs to the communities rather than to a donor cycle.
Indigenous economic development in the Brazilian Amazon Early implementation
Attempt
Indigenous organisations and partners in the Brazilian Amazon are building economic activity based on territorial products and knowledge.
Conditions
Demarcated territories, community organisation, and markets that increasingly value provenance.
Mechanism
Community enterprise, processing and market access built around what the territory sustains.
Outcome
Early implementation. No measured outcome is claimed.
For whom
Participating Indigenous communities.
Cost / trade-off
Not established.
Unintended effects
Not established.
Transferability
Too early to judge. It is included because it shows communities as designers and owners, not recipients.
NODOS and the viche productive chain, Buenaventura, Colombia Early implementation
Attempt
An Afro-descendant productive chain around viche in Buenaventura was organised and formalised with community leadership.
Conditions
An Afro-descendant territory with deep productive tradition, historic exclusion from formal markets, and recent legal recognition of the product.
Mechanism
Organising producers, protecting the tradition in law and building routes to market that keep value in the territory.
Outcome
Early implementation. Economic outcomes for producers are not established here.
For whom
Afro-descendant producers in and around Buenaventura.
Cost / trade-off
Not established.
Unintended effects
Not established.
Transferability
The pattern, formalising a tradition on the community's own terms, is transferable in principle; the legal recognition behind it is specific.
Argentina: technology cluster resilience Contested / mixed
Attempt
Argentina's technology clusters continued to grow through repeated macroeconomic volatility.
Conditions
Strong technical talent and export orientation, inside an economy with recurring currency and inflation shocks.
Mechanism
Export services, remote work for foreign clients, and firm-level adaptation to volatility.
Outcome
Contested. Sector resilience and talent emigration are both part of the record, and this case is not presented as a success story.
For whom
Firms and workers inside the clusters; not established beyond them.
Cost / trade-off
Volatility that firms adapt to also pushes talent abroad.
Unintended effects
Not established.
Transferability
What may travel is the adaptation itself. What should not be assumed is that adaptation under volatility amounts to a development strategy.

Leadership interpretation

Through the LEAD48 4P Leadership Lens

The region remains the subject. The 4Ps help interpret what the evidence means for leadership.

What the evidence asks us to examine

People adapt. Process channels or fragments. Planet tests. Portfolio chooses. Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme
How each P reads in this region

People

Who carries the consequences?

Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

The evidence asks Where does the region's adaptive capacity actually live, and who carries the cost of using it?

People provide adaptive capacity. Across the region, work, trade, migration, care and enterprise are sustained by people who find ways through incomplete systems, including Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities whose governance and productive knowledge institutions have often failed to recognise or scale.

Process

What systems shape the outcome?

Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

The evidence asks Which systems turn that capacity into opportunity, and which fragment it?

Process channels or fragments. Productive, institutional and territorial systems decide whether adaptive capability becomes secure participation or stays a workaround, and legitimacy follows what institutions actually deliver rather than what they are entitled to do.

  • Source AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay (2024)

    Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

    Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally in the United Nations E-Government Development Index between 2022 and 2024, with a score of 0.9006. It remains first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas after the United States (0.9194). The work is led by AGESIC under the Agenda Uruguay Digital 2025.

    Published
    2024
    Evidence period
    UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022
    Geography
    Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean
    Limitations
    A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.

Planet

What must endure?

Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

The evidence asks What does the region's environment already test, and what must endure through it?

Planet tests. Disaster exposure, water, energy, food systems, land and territorial stewardship set the terms leadership works within, and they test whether systems can absorb repeated shocks. This is broader than a climate file: it is what has to keep working when the next shock lands.

  • Source World Bank (2024)

    World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

    Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

    Published
    2024-11-12
    Evidence period
    Announced at COP29, November 2024
    Geography
    Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
    Limitations
    An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.

Portfolio

What must leaders choose?

Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

The evidence asks What gets funded, protected, scaled, stopped or deferred when both money and implementation capacity are scarce?

Portfolio chooses. The binding constraint is rarely ambition: it is fiscal space and the capacity to implement. Choosing what to fund, protect, scale, stop and defer, and who does the work, is where regional leadership is exercised.

  • Source World Bank (2024)

    World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

    Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

    Published
    2024-11-12
    Evidence period
    Announced at COP29, November 2024
    Geography
    Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
    Limitations
    An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
  • Source Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (2025)

    Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

    The "25 by 2025 Initiative", which set out to cut the region's food import bill of "more than $6B" by 25 percent by the end of 2025, has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5. CARICOM cites "uncertainties in the global trade arena", Hurricane Beryl's effect on agriculture and supply-chain disruption. It reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund.

    Published
    2025-02-21
    Evidence period
    2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030
    Geography
    CARICOM member states
    Limitations
    A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.

How the 4P Leadership Lens works

SDG connections Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

Which Goals does this touch?

A Goal appears here only when a cited source supports the link.

  • SDG 8
    Decent work and economic growth Primary

    8.3: Promote development-oriented policies that support productive activities and the growth of micro-, small- and medium-sized enterprises

    Adaptive capacity that does not convert into productive participation is the region's central question. Evidence-backed

  • SDG 9
    Industry, innovation and infrastructure Primary

    9.2: Promote inclusive and sustainable industrialization

    Productive transformation and technology diffusion across uneven productive systems. Evidence-backed

  • SDG 10
    Reduced inequalities Primary

    10.2: Empower and promote the social, economic and political inclusion of all

    Territorial and social fragmentation decides who participates in what the region produces. Evidence-backed

  • SDG 13
    Climate action Primary

    13.1: Strengthen resilience and adaptive capacity to climate-related hazards and natural disasters

    Repeated shocks against thin fiscal space make resilience a present-day allocation decision. Evidence-backed

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
  • SDG 16
    Peace, justice and strong institutions Primary

    16.6: Develop effective, accountable and transparent institutions at all levels

    Legitimacy follows what institutions deliver, which is the region's institutional-performance question. Evidence-backed

    • Source AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay (2024)

      Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

      Uruguay rose from 35th to 25th globally in the United Nations E-Government Development Index between 2022 and 2024, with a score of 0.9006. It remains first in Latin America and the Caribbean for the sixth consecutive edition and second in the Americas after the United States (0.9194). The work is led by AGESIC under the Agenda Uruguay Digital 2025.

      Published
      2024
      Evidence period
      UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022
      Geography
      Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean
      Limitations
      A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.
View the 4 supporting Goals
  • SDG 1
    No poverty Supporting

    1.5: Build the resilience of the poor and those in vulnerable situations to climate-related extreme events and other shocks

    Shocks fall hardest on those with least protection, and recovery consumes the space meant for prevention. Evidence-backed

    • Source World Bank (2024)

      World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

      Climate Resilient Debt Clauses "allow eligible countries to defer principal and/or interest repayments on IBRD and IDA loans for up to two years" after a catastrophic event. The clause was expanded to cover all natural disasters, including droughts, floods and health emergencies, and to 45 eligible small and vulnerable states, of which 14 had included it in loan agreements. St Vincent and the Grenadines exercised the deferral after Hurricane Beryl.

      Published
      2024-11-12
      Evidence period
      Announced at COP29, November 2024
      Geography
      Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean
      Limitations
      An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.
  • SDG 4
    Quality education Supporting

    4.4: Substantially increase the number of youth and adults who have relevant skills for employment, decent jobs and entrepreneurship

    Skills decide who can absorb new technology and who is left adapting around it. Evidence-backed

  • SDG 5
    Gender equality Supporting

    5.4: Recognize and value unpaid care and domestic work

    Care work sustains the region's adaptive capacity and is largely unrecognised in its productive accounts. Evidence-backed

  • SDG 17
    Partnerships for the goals Supporting

    17.17: Encourage and promote effective public, public-private and civil society partnerships

    Regional integration and community-owned delivery are how much of this work actually gets done. Evidence-backed

    • Source Caribbean Community (CARICOM) (2025)

      Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

      The "25 by 2025 Initiative", which set out to cut the region's food import bill of "more than $6B" by 25 percent by the end of 2025, has been "extended to 2030" and renamed Vision 25 by 2025+5. CARICOM cites "uncertainties in the global trade arena", Hurricane Beryl's effect on agriculture and supply-chain disruption. It reports about a 24 percent increase in regional food production from 2022 to late 2024, and a US$100M Regional Agriculture Loan Fund.

      Published
      2025-02-21
      Evidence period
      2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030
      Geography
      CARICOM member states
      Limitations
      A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.
Why these Goals, and why these are primary

Primary Goals carry the region's inquiry; supporting Goals are touched by it. They are not equally weighted.

The movement

What this movement asks

Theme Adaptation, fragmentation, transformation

Broad window Thu 20 May, about 1:00 PM to 4:00 PM Toronto time. In São Paulo: Thu 20 May, about 2:00 PM to 5:00 PM.

Inquiry themes this movement feeds Who keeps the value when it is created · Fund, sequence, defer or stop: when every choice is defensible. Where you live does not decide where you fit.

LEAD48 curates the conversations inside this movement from the research on this page and the perspectives below. You do not need to choose a session: bring what you know to the inquiry, and the matching is LEAD48's work.

Contributor expressions of interest are not open.

The shape of a movement

How a movement moves

The same beats in every region, in the same order. What fills them, and how long they take, is this region's own.

View the beats every movement runs through
  1. Baton Handover In

    The incoming and outgoing regions are both live. Intellectual content, not an emcee transition.

  2. Opening Regional Provocation

    One strong regional voice frames the movement: what is happening in this region right now, and why should the rest of the world care?

  3. Regional Reality

    The evidence: what is actually true in this region.

  4. Responses, Experiments and Tensions

    The practical core: what is being tried, and where it is contested.

  5. Regional Synthesis

    What we learned, what challenged our assumptions and where we disagreed.

  6. Baton Question + Handover Out

    The signature moment. The baton never simply moves: it evolves.

Perspectives sought Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What perspectives strengthen this inquiry?

The kinds of knowledge and experience this inquiry needs. They describe perspectives, not places: one person may bring several, and a strong case or a well-evidenced challenge counts as much as a title.

View the knowledge this movement needs
  • Informal economy and productivity

    Knowledge required Works with informal firms or workers and understands informality as livelihood as well as measurement.

    Why this is needed The region's central condition is misread when informality is treated only as non-compliance.

  • Productive development

    Knowledge required Has designed or run productive development policy, including where it failed to reach smaller firms.

    Why this is needed Productive transformation is the priority the region leads with.

  • Caribbean small-state leadership

    Knowledge required Has led or advised in a Caribbean small state under fiscal and disaster constraint.

    Why this is needed The Caribbean is integral to this region, and its question about leadership under constraint needs its own voice.

  • Climate finance and resilience

    Knowledge required Understands resilience financing instruments and what they do and do not solve after a disaster.

    Why this is needed Resilience here is a live allocation decision, not a future environmental concern.

  • Public-sector implementation

    Knowledge required Has delivered public services or infrastructure and can describe where delivery actually breaks.

    Why this is needed Institutional legitimacy is being decided in delivery.

  • Indigenous governance and stewardship

    Knowledge required Holds or works within Indigenous governance, territorial stewardship or community enterprise.

    Why this is needed Indigenous communities are designers, owners and knowledge holders in this region, not a vulnerability category.

  • Afro-descendant economic and territorial development

    Knowledge required Works in Afro-descendant territorial or economic development, from inside the community.

    Why this is needed Afro-descendant productive knowledge is part of the region's leadership capacity.

  • Youth and the transition into work

    Knowledge required Works on the transition from education into work, including informal pathways.

    Why this is needed Who enters productive participation, and how, is the region's next decade.

  • Women and the care economy

    Knowledge required Works on care work, its economics and its distribution.

    Why this is needed Care sustains the region's adaptive capacity and is largely absent from its productive accounts.

  • AI and digital productive transformation

    Knowledge required Has put digital or AI systems into firms or governments in the region and seen who benefited.

    Why this is needed Diffusion, not adoption, decides who captures the value.

  • MSMEs and entrepreneurship

    Knowledge required Runs or supports micro, small or medium enterprises in the region.

    Why this is needed Most employment sits here, and so does most unconverted adaptive capacity.

  • Migration and remittances

    Knowledge required Works with migration as an economic and family system, not as a crisis.

    Why this is needed Migration connects labour, skills, demographics, remittances and productive structures at both ends.

  • Security and institutional capacity

    Knowledge required Understands insecurity through its effect on institutions, investment and daily life.

    Why this is needed Security is a real regional condition and must be discussed without sensationalism.

  • Regional integration

    Knowledge required Has worked inside regional institutions or integration mechanisms.

    Why this is needed Several of the region's responses only exist at regional scale.

  • Infrastructure and project execution

    Knowledge required Has executed infrastructure projects and can explain the gap between commitment and completion.

    Why this is needed Implementation capacity is as scarce as fiscal space in much of the region.

The baton

The question moves

  1. It arrives. North America hands this movement the question.
  2. This region changes it. Everything above is what it is changed by.
  3. It leaves changed. Australia & Pacific receives whatever this movement earns in the room.

No question is written in advance. Each movement's question is earned live, in the room, and published here once it has been.

Global report contribution

What this movement will contribute

How this movement feeds the report

What this movement will contribute to the LEAD48 Global Leadership Report 2027. Every field is filled from the live movement, and disagreement is preserved rather than resolved.

What this movement finds is written in the room during the relay and becomes its part of the LEAD48 Global Leadership Report 2027. How the five outputs work

Research gaps and limitations Evidence-grounded synthesisLocked for the programme

What this evidence cannot show

These are limitations, not blockers. They are published so a reader can judge the evidence for themselves.

View what this evidence cannot show
  • Several response cases carry no verified figures

    Costa Rica's medical-device cluster, the Costa Rican Indigenous forest arrangement, the AIDESEP programme, Brazilian Amazon Indigenous enterprise, the viche chain in Buenaventura and Argentina's technology clusters are described from the locked research without a primary-source figure attached. They are marked accordingly rather than given numbers they do not have.

    Affects: Responses and experiments

  • The prevailing conditions are syntheses, not quotations

    The five conditions are LEAD48's reading of the region's evidence. They are traceable to that evidence but are not claims lifted from a single source, and they are labelled evidence-grounded synthesis for that reason.

    Affects: Prevailing conditions

  • Food production and the food import bill are not the same measure

    CARICOM reports a regional production increase; it does not demonstrate that the import bill fell by the target share. The case says so rather than treating one as the other.

    Affects: Responses and experiments

  • Subregional depth is uneven

    Six subregional realities are named, but the evidence behind them is thicker for the Caribbean and the Southern Cone than for Central America and the Andean economies.

    Affects: Subregional realities

Research and evidence

See the evidence

Every claim on this page links here. Participants' contributions do not statistically represent the whole region.

View all 3 sources
  1. World Bank Expands Lifeline to Small States hit by Disasters

    World Bank · 2024-11-12 · Evidence period: Announced at COP29, November 2024 · Geography: Small states worldwide, including the Caribbean

    Population: Eligible small states with IBRD and IDA loans

    Limitations: An institutional announcement of a financing instrument, not an evaluation of it. Eligibility is not adoption: most eligible countries had not yet written the clause into loan agreements, and nothing here measures what deferral achieved for a recovering economy.

  2. Food Security Initiative Expanded, Extended to 2030

    Caribbean Community (CARICOM) · 2025-02-21 · Evidence period: 2022 to late 2024, with the target extended to 2030 · Geography: CARICOM member states

    Population: The region's food system: producers, importers and member governments

    Limitations: A communiqué from the Heads of Government meeting, not an independent evaluation. The production increase is self-reported at regional level and is not the same measure as the import-bill target the initiative was set against.

  3. Uruguay asciende 10 posiciones a nivel global en el índice de gobierno digital

    AGESIC (Agencia de Gobierno Electrónico y Sociedad de la Información y del Conocimiento), Uruguay · 2024 · Evidence period: UN E-Government Survey 2024, compared with 2022 · Geography: Uruguay, compared with Latin America and the Caribbean

    Population: National digital government services

    Limitations: A government agency reporting its own country's index position. The E-Government Development Index measures online service provision, infrastructure and human capital, not whether services work for the people who need them most.